Finn's Take· TL;DRAlaska's U.S. Senate contest is shaping up to be one of the strangest and most consequential races in the country — and three days after Election Day, it still has no winner. The outcome of the U.S. Senate race in Alaska was unclear as Democrats scored a sweeping victory in the midterm elections that delivered them control of the House of Representatives and the Senate. But Alaska's piece of that puzzle remains stubbornly unsettled. With an unusual voting system and a legal challenge by the Trump administration, it could be weeks until a result is known.
Incumbent Republican Dan Sullivan, first elected in 2014, is locked in a tight battle with Democratic challenger Mary Peltola, a centrist who served one term in the U.S. House of Representatives from 2022 to 2025. Senate Democratic leader Chuck Schumer heavily courted Peltola — the last Democrat to win any statewide election in Alaska — to run for Senate. Peltola had narrowly lost her congressional seat in 2024 before ultimately deciding to enter the Senate race in early 2026.
What makes this race truly bizarre is the presence of a second Dan Sullivan on the ballot. Democratic nominee Mary Peltola is facing two candidates named Dan Sullivan in the Alaska Senate election — one of whom is the Republican incumbent. The lawsuit filed by the Trump administration cites theoretical voter confusion over the appearance of the second Sullivan on the ballot, arguing it could siphon votes away from the incumbent Republican Sullivan and benefit Peltola.
The DOJ filed an amended version of its original complaint, adding details from a New York Times article alleging efforts by people in the campaign of Democratic nominee Mary Peltola to recruit a retired schoolteacher named Dan J. Sullivan into the race. Peltola has repeatedly denied any involvement with the second Sullivan. However, the Times reported that her campaign was directly involved in recruiting Dan J. Sullivan, a retired schoolteacher, to run as a spoiler. A federal judge dismissed the DOJ's Alaska Senate election lawsuit after finding the government failed to establish the redressability requirement for Article III standing. A federal appeals court does not appear likely to quickly issue a decision in the so-far-unsuccessful lawsuit ordered by Trump that seeks to stop the race's certification if Sullivan loses.
Alaska runs a ranked-choice voting system, which means voters can rank candidates on their ballots in order of preference rather than selecting only one. If no candidate receives more than half of voters' first-place votes, officials eliminate the last-place finisher and reallocate those ballots to voters' next choices until one candidate has a majority. The race also has two other candidates on the ballot beyond Sullivan and Peltola: an independent candidate and retired teacher Daniel J. Sullivan, and another Republican, Gerald Heikes.
Despite their small numbers, ballots for the Petersburg Sullivan and Heikes could help decide the winner of the race under Alaska's ranked-choice voting system. In that case, both could be eliminated and their ballots redistributed to their supporters' next-ranked candidates, helping determine whether Peltola or Sullivan wins. Adding to the complexity, Alaska allows up to 10 days to receive absentee ballots sent from within the U.S. — a timeline that can be critical for ballots from rural communities often accessible only by air or water.
Ranked-choice tabulation is scheduled to take place on November 18, and election results are set to be certified on November 25. With such a narrow margin separating the candidates, the race could hinge on ballots that were mailed or have to be flown in from remote communities. Peltola's campaign said in a statement, "The numbers are clear: when every vote is counted, Mary Peltola will be elected as Alaska's next United States Senator."
The outcome carries weight far beyond Alaska's borders. Alaska's election could determine which party has a majority in the Senate. With legal battles still simmering and thousands of ballots yet to be counted from one of the most geographically challenging states in the nation, Alaska is poised to remain the country's most closely watched — and most complicated — race well into the weeks ahead.