Ask Finn← Discover
Trending

Who Really Deserves Credit for America's Historic Drop in Urban Crime

By Hayden Walsh · Saturday, November 7, 2026
Finn's Take· TL;DR
  • U.S. urban homicides dropped 38 percent since 2020, with some cities recording fewest murders in decades.
  • Trump administration credits National Guard deployments for crime decline, but research shows crime was already falling beforehand.
  • Analysis by Center for American Progress found $1.7 billion Guard deployment had no measurable effect on violent crime.
See this from any side — with sources:
Left takeNeutralRight take

Crime Is Falling — But the Debate Over Why Is Just Getting Started

The United States is in a multiyear trend of falling rates of homicides and other crimes in cities nationwide, ushering in a period of relative safety that rivals the years before the pandemic. The numbers are striking: homicides tumbled by about 38 percent since 2020 in 52 of the largest cities, some of which are now recording the fewest murders in half a century. But behind that good news lies a fierce political battle — one centered on who, or what, actually deserves the credit.

The drop in overall crime comes at a delicate time in the nation's political debate as President Donald Trump continues to cite crime as justification for deploying the National Guard and other federal law enforcement personnel into major American cities. The administration credits the decline to the deportation of criminal illegal aliens and the deterrent effect of National Guard deployments. Critics, however, say the data tells a very different story.

The National Guard Deployment: A $1.7 Billion Gamble

A major analysis by the Center for American Progress revealed that the Trump administration's costly and controversial deployments of the National Guard to Los Angeles, Washington, Memphis, and New Orleans have failed to reduce violent crime. If current deployments are extended through the end of 2026, they are projected to cost American taxpayers more than $1.7 billion — even as the 11 cities targeted by the administration saw an average 14 percent decrease in violent crime and a 22 percent decrease in murders in the 12 months preceding federal intervention.

The findings suggest that the deployments have not reduced violent crime, as incidents were already trending downward well before Trump deployed the National Guard to various cities. "What we find is that across multiple cities, multiple datasets, and multiple time windows, we find no effect that violent crime actually did change post the National Guard deployment in any of the cities," said Chandler Hall of CAP. FBI data and other crime statistics showed that crime began to spike in 2020 and then started to drop after 2022, before Trump was elected to his second term in 2024.

A Politically Charged Standoff

Trump is claiming credit for Washington's dramatic crime decline a year after sending thousands of National Guard troops to the nation's capital, but the evidence shows crime was already falling before his federal intervention, and the extent to which his policies accelerated that decline remains disputed. The controversy escalated sharply in September, when Trump announced a lawsuit against the Center for American Progress after the think tank published its report claiming National Guard deployments to American cities had no effect on violent crime — a finding Trump called a politically motivated fraud.

Research from the Niskanen Center found that the National Guard seems to have impacted mostly low-level opportunistic property crimes — things like petty thefts and people breaking into cars — while all types of crime had already been going down. Researchers attempted to distinguish between the effect the National Guard had and what was already occurring in cities before deployment. That nuance, however, has been largely lost in the political noise.

What's Actually Driving the Decline?

An analysis of federal and state crime data shows that almost all of Trump's deployments have targeted cities with lower violent crime rates than many other American cities. Among large American cities — those with 250,000 or more residents — Trump ordered soldiers deployed to just one whose violent crime rate is among the 15 worst in the United States. That raises pointed questions about whether the Guard was ever sent where it was needed most.

Homicides across 52 of the biggest cities fell by about 20 percent last year, led by cities like Seattle (down 42 percent), Denver (41 percent), and Phoenix (14 percent). Even cities long in the national spotlight saw significant improvements, including Memphis and Baltimore, down 26 and 31 percent respectively. These broad, geographically diverse declines suggest forces well beyond any single federal policy are at work. As the debate over military deployments, taxpayer costs, and political credit continues to intensify, one thing is clear: America's cities are genuinely safer — and understanding exactly why matters enormously for how the country invests in public safety going forward.

Have a question about this story?
Ask Finn — answers grounded in this article, from any viewpoint.