Finn's Take· TL;DRWhen you book a flight, hail a ride, or add something to your online cart, the price you see might not be the same price your neighbor sees — and federal regulators want to know exactly why. The Federal Trade Commission is demanding information from Walmart, Uber, and seven other companies on whether and how they use consumers' personal data — such as location, browsing history, and income — to set individual prices, wages, and job offers. The practice has a name that regulators are now using openly: surveillance pricing.
The advance of algorithmic pricing technology, including tools that incorporate AI, has fueled concern that companies are able to set prices for shoppers on an individual basis in order to extract the maximum price each shopper would be willing to pay. Personalized pricing strategies are difficult to observe from the outside, because they serve different prices to different people. The FTC study aims to fill in that knowledge gap, demanding comprehensive information about the tools, strategies, and data companies use, as well as how they affect prices, wages, and job offers.
The FTC ordered three airlines — Delta, United, and JetBlue — two ride-share companies — Uber and Lyft — two delivery platforms — DoorDash and Instacart — and two retailers — Target and Walmart — to file special reports on how they set prices and pay. The orders were issued under Section 6(b) of the FTC Act, which grants the agency authority to compel detailed business information for research and policy purposes. The companies have 45 days to respond.
Under the orders, each company must provide information that will allow the FTC to assess whether the pricing for a ticket, ride-share, food delivery, or other product or service varies from one person to the next based on factors such as participation in loyalty programs or analysis of personal data by algorithmic systems. The probe also extends beyond what consumers pay. Ride-share and food-delivery companies may compensate workers on a shifting basis using murky formulas that exploit drivers' personal data, including phone usage and payments they have historically agreed to.
Several of the named companies were quick to deny wrongdoing. JetBlue told reporters that it "does not use personal information or web browsing history to set individual pricing." Delta said it has zero tolerance for discriminatory or predatory pricing, complies with pricing and advertising law, and has no fare product in use, in testing, or planned that targets customers with individualized offers based on personal data. But denials alone aren't enough to satisfy the FTC.
The FTC probe follows an order in July 2024 to eight companies seeking information about how they facilitated the alleged surveillance of consumers by third-party companies. Those eight previously queried "middleman consultancies" allegedly sold surveillance pricing tools to businesses rather than setting algorithm-driven pricing themselves. The agency acknowledged it "learned nothing about actual pricing decisions from the 2024 study," and said this new effort "corrects the Commission's mistaken 2024 approach" by demanding information directly from companies who may be engaging in personalized pricing.
FTC Chairman Andrew Ferguson stated that "consumers deserve to know whether companies use their web surfing habits or other personal data to estimate the highest price they can charge each consumer," adding that workers also deserve to know if their compensation is affected by how companies use their personal data. Ferguson also noted that the agency lacks authority to ban personalized pricing outright, but will enforce the law against businesses that hide how personal data affects prices.
Legislation has been introduced in several states to bar surveillance pricing and electronic shelf labels that could be used to set various prices for shoppers based on their habits and online information. Experts have warned that, unlike uniform pricing, bespoke pricing enabled by big data and artificial intelligence gives companies little incentive to offer discounts to those who can't afford market prices — a concern that cuts to the heart of fairness in the modern marketplace. With the 45-day response window now ticking, the results of this investigation could reshape how Americans understand — and challenge — the prices they're shown every day.